TED演讲之寻找真理:科学可以回答道德问题(6)

Now, many of you might worry that the notion of well-being is truly undefined,

或许在你们之中,有许多人会担心这所谓的幸福该如何界定

and seemingly perpetually open to be re-construed.

这似乎没有一定的标准

And so, how therefore can there be an objective notion of well-being?

而且,怎么可能有一种完全客观的人身幸福的标准存在呢?

Well, consider by analogy, the concept of physical health.

如果是这样,难道因为对身体健康的概念

The concept of physical health is undefined.

没有一个真正的定论

As we just heard from Michael Specter, it has changed over the years.

如同Michael Specter适才说道,这些概念也会改变

When this statue was carved the average life expectancy was probably 30.

在这个雕像产生的年代,人类的平均寿命是30

It's now around 80 in the developed world.

现在已发展国家的平均寿命是80

There may come a time when we meddle with our genomes in such a way that not being able to run a marathon

也许有一天,因为我们对基因的研究,

at age 200 will be considered a profound disability.

200岁不能跑马拉松是一种残疾

People will send you donations when you're in that condition.

如果你有这种状况,人们会捐钱给你

Notice that the fact that the concept of health is open, genuinely open for revision, does not make it vacuous.

我们知道健康的观念会改变,随时都可以重新思考,这不代表这些讨论是毫无意义的

The distinction between a healthy person and a dead one

一个健康的人和一个死人之间的差别

is about as clear and consequential as any we make in science.

在科学或理论里是一样的

Another thing to notice is there may be many peaks on the moral landscape:

另外一个该注意的事情是道德地图上虽然有很多山巅

There may be equivalent ways to thrive;

是有可能可以一起努力

there may be equivalent ways to organize a human society so as to maximize human flourishing.

一起找出一个管理人类社会的方法,一起找出最大的幸福

Now, why wouldn't this undermine an objective morality?

为什么我们不能将这个当作客观道德的基础?

Well think of how we talk about food:

想象我们讨论食物的方式

I would never be tempted to argue to you that there must be one right food to eat.

我永远不会和你争辩人类应该有吃的自由

演讲简介

几个世纪来,科学被排拒在善恶对错的问题以外。Sam Harris提出科学不但可以,更应当成为道德问题的准则,为人类设立新人道价值,带领我们走向真正的幸福生活。

NSDA“SDcamps”全国英语演讲与辩论大赛(大学组)/SDcamps全国中小学生英语演讲与辩论大会(中小学及幼儿组)/美式辩论赛(以下简称大赛/大会)现诚招全国省市合作伙伴或城市合伙人,共同进行推广NSDA赛事品牌、举办赛事及培训活动、开展素质教育、美式营地项目等多方面合作。

我们希望认同NSDA理念,有赛事组织经验,或有教育资源,特别是有理想有热情的机构或个人一起携手,共同推广NSDA品牌、赛事及素质教育。以机构的形式,或以城市合伙人的方式均可。具体的赛事组织、盈利模式,欢迎电话或微信咨询。

详情查看:NSDA(全美演讲与辩论联盟)赛事活动诚招全国各城市合作伙伴

发表回复

您的电子邮箱地址不会被公开。 必填项已用*标注

此站点使用Akismet来减少垃圾评论。了解我们如何处理您的评论数据